Evidence provide scientific data to support your claim. Aug 29, 2018 claims, evidence, and reasoning introduction lesson plan minilesson. Claims, evidence, and reasoning introduction lesson plan. Claimevidencereasoning or cer is a writing strategy that can develop.
In an interview with students, mits kerry emmanuel said, at the end of the day, its just raw curiosity. Evidence the scientific data that supports the claim. Page 2 sum up your claim, evidence and reasoning in a few sentences below. I scaffold this through the use claim evidence reasoning which is a graphic organizer for the development of an argument through the use of claims, evidence, and reasoning. Aug 22, 20 i introduce claim evidence reasoning using a murder mystery, including a rubric that is my modification of the cer rubric from mcneill and krajcik. Parts 4 and 5 focus on expressing evidence based claims in writing. This graphic organizer introduces the concept of claim, evidence and reasoning to students in the intermediate grades by including the definition, an example, and key words for each term. What did you observe in this photograph that supports your claim. The reasoning should usually be at least a few sentences in length. Jeff rohr, a fifthgrade teacher in beaver dam, wisconsin, suggests using an audi commercial to introduce students to the components of an explanation by asking them to identify the claim, the evidence, and the reasoningor rulethat connects the evidence to the little girls claim that her dad is a space alien let the inquiry begin as you work with your students on cer throughout the. Parts 4 and 5 focus on expressing evidencebased claims in writing.
I introduce claim evidence reasoning using a murder mystery, including a rubric that is my modification of the cer rubric from mcneill and krajcik. Part 3 focuses on preparing to express evidencebased claims by organizing evidence and thinking. Apr 12, 2015 create a graphic organizer box 2 claim. Claim evidence reasoning c er writing graphic organizer remember. Includes a poster to explain the fundamentals of cer as well as a simple grading rubric. This simple, fun and educational animation from mcgrawhill sra flex literacy provides a brief introduction to claims and supporting evidence.
The students explanation or answer, as you may have guessed, will consist of three parts. Science notebooks a tool for increasing student understanding of inquiry and science content. Designing arguments that rely on clearly defined claims, evidence and reasoning is a science practice sp7. Claim, evidence and reasoning statement 21 claim, evidence and reasoning template 22 claim, evidence and reasoning example 23 claim, evidence and reasoning rubric 24. Claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer parents as. Data are observations or measurements or results from an experiment. Your evidence should be appropriate relevant and sufficient enough to convince someone that your claim is correct. Once the minilesson is complete, the cards can be placed at a center for sorting practice.
Jul 26, 2018 cer stands for claim, evidence, and reasoning. This organization is designed to strengthen the precision of instruction and assessment, as well as. Getting students to understand cer is important because it helps them think through the scientific process. Evaluating authors claims use the organizer below to trace and evaluate the argument and specific claims in the text you just read. Claimsevidencereasoning independence school district. Claim evidence reasoning template pdf ten lessons ive learned from claim evidence reasoning template pdf claim evidence reasoning template pdf claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer a great form to guide a parentteacher conference. What evidence makes you reasonably believe your claim is true.
The order that you use it doesnt matter questions first, claim first, evidence first, or reason. Claimevidencereasoning cer student graphic organizer question. Claim evidence reasoning c e r writing graphic organizer remember. As the year goes on i remove most of the scaffolds until ultimately the students just get a prompt or question. Scaffolding for claims, evidence and reasoning an introduction to science unit purpose in this sampling from an introduction to science unit for middle school students, 7 experiment activities are showcased which build up students abilities to make claims, support them with factual, scientific evidence and then provide reasoning, a scientific.
In order to continue to promote organized argumentation. Once students have practiced the concept of supporting a claim with evidence, you can use our graphic organizer for independent work. Evidence guide graphic organizer this strategy also follows the detective type thinking, similar to main ideadetail graphic organizer. My favorite lesson plan for teaching claim, evidence, and reasoning. Students first need to be able to understand a theory, then the student finds evidence that supports this theory, as well as goes against the theory. Reasoning is the explanation that connects your claim to the evidence that supports it. Claim evidence reasoning template pdf ten lessons ive learned from claim evidence reasoning template pdf claim evidence reasoning template pdf. The reason there is a reasoning box below every evidence box is because we need to explain how each piece of evidence supports the claim. Key terms and concepts argumentation is the process of supporting claims, assertions, proposed solutions, conclusions, or models with solid reasoning based on.
The following graphic organizer shows different types of evidence that was used in passage 2 letter to the editor example of types of evidence claim. I claim that the relationship between the salt and the water is that they weigh the same before and after mixing. Claims evidence reasoning cer writing graphic organizer. Introduce scientific thinking while building scientific writing skills with the claim evidence reasoning graphic organizer. Includes appropriate and sufficient scientific principles. You can find the slides i used here, and here is the graphic organizer that i use. While both sides make an acceptable case, the letter provides a bettersupported argument. The cer examples are based on two commercials and one. You can use this as prewriting for an essay or in preparation for an inclass debate. Argument essay graphic organizer revised fall 2015.
This simple, fun and educational animation from mcgrawhill sra flex literacy provides a brief introduction to claims and supporting evidence a key learning objective. Claim evidence reasoning cer student graphic organizer question. This looks the same as the i stage except student voice takes over in terms of offering ideas and providing rationale. Supporting claims with evidence the curriculum corner 123. Parts 12 focus on making evidencebased claims as readers. Provides accurate and complete reasoning that links evidence to claim. Rubricsthere are two different rubrics provided here. Cerworksheetbyericbrunsell,university ofwisconsinoshkosh. Evidence comes from sources, fieldwork, and research. The perfect graphic organizer to help students construct a variety of essays, this product clearly illustrates the connections between the claim, reasons, and evidence allowing students to better organize their thinking for persuasive, argumentative, and informative essays. The purpose of this graphic organizer is to help make connections between the. This question is based on a phenomena or lab experience. Students are required to develop a scientific argument with the inclusion of a claim, evidence, and reasoning.
What is a specific observation or data from the lab that supports your claim. Claimevidencereasoning pdf and pdf is a framework for writing scientific explanations. Strategies for teaching argumentative writing integrating reading and writing. Bob should be elected class president because hes a natural leader. Teacher provides frequent opportunities for students to engage in studentdriven argumentation. I keep a stack of copies of the argument from evidence graphic organizer readily available until. Use your own question, prompt or lab with this versatile and easy to use template. Develop claims and counterclaims fairly and thoroughly, supplying the most relevant data and evidence for each while pointing out the strengths and limitations of both claims and counterclaims in a discipline. I claim that we can make a solution by combining salt and water.
It is a great tool for common core and teaching students about text evidence. Sep 25, 2012 the claim, evidence, reasoning framework is a scaffolded way to teach the scientific method. Based on scientific principles each piece of evidence may have a different justification for. Linking claims and evidence with analysis writing focus. As part of their lab handout they get a prompt that looks like this. Claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer you can use this claim, evidence, reasoning graphic organizer for many subjects or topics. Explain the analogy making an argument is like taking your reader on a roller coaster. Reasoning linking the evidence to the claim and proving the study can be done only when the reasoning is initiated. Evidence of students selfmonitoring and evaluation of their own learning evidence of differentiated instruction to meet the needs of diverse students strategies that scaffold students progression to high level critical thinking skills evidence of students background and experiences being used to. After completing the graphic organizer, students should be ready to develop a clear. After being posed with a question or observation, students have to make a claim similar to forming a hypothesis, provide evidence to support their claim, and explain their reasoning.
In order for your reader to stay with you, you need to strap him into that roller coaster argument properly for the entire time. Claims, evidence, reasoning cer graphic organizer 1 tobin k8. The purpose of this graphic organizer is to help make connections between the claim, the evidence of that claim, and the reason that the evidence supports that claim. There is a claim and enough evidence is collected, but only when one starts thinking about the how and why it can help to conclude on the study favoring the claim. State the evidence what evidence is provided in the texts refute the evidence argue against the evidence and why the stance that you have selected is the better supported concludingtransitional sentences end the paragraph with information that reasserts your position as a whole. Does not provide reasoning, or only provides recording that does not link evidence to claim. Displaying all worksheets related to claim evidence and reasoning. I think almost everybody that gets seriously into science is driven by curiosity. You can use the cer graphic organizer resource with your students to help. Parts 12 focus on making evidence based claims as readers. Claim evidence reasoning cer framework as both learning and assessment tasks for students. Argument from evidence graphic organizer betterlesson. The organizer is a powerpoint slide, but it prints like a regular sheet of paper. After looking for patterns in your observations, what claim can you make about this photograph.
Dec, 2018 reasoning linking the evidence to the claim and proving the study can be done only when the reasoning is initiated. A statement that answers your question scientific data that support the claim data need to be appropriate pictures, graphs, table observation reasoning how your evidence justifies your claim. Worksheets are how do you know that helping students write about claims, claim evidence reasoning cer writing scientific, argumentative writing for 6 12 social studies, claims evidence and reasoning guide, claims evidence reasoning, claim evidence reasoning now symposium, scaffolding for claims. When using a graphic organizer, be clear to students about the purpose for the structure.
Stenhousepublishers cerworksheetbyericbrunsell,universityofwisconsinoshkosh claims. A claim is the position statement or the key point of your argument three types of claims. Creating opportunities for students to debate multiple claims. Part 3 focuses on preparing to express evidence based claims by organizing evidence and thinking. Cer all starts with a question asked by the teacher. Repeats evidence and links it to some scientific principles, but not sufficient. This graphic organizer reflects the change made to put the most convincing argument right after the counterclaim and right before the conclusion. By the end, the idea is that the lack of a claim, evidence, or reasoning would make anyone in class scream. Developing evidence for yourself, analyzing counter arguments, and making wellreasoned claims leads to confidence and assertiveness. Page 1 use the graphic organizer below to construct an argument from evidence. It also integrates this concept with finding the theme of a text. Use this graphic organizer to support student thinking within the cer framework and as a. It shows a detailed understanding of the scientific principles involved and uses correct science vocabulary. Integrating the claimevidencereasoning framework into my.
972 772 1536 1216 501 205 793 1034 1362 107 1115 1483 676 1569 1045 430 818 576 755 1348 890 95 650 436 1167 1305 854 992 948 455 342 624